A cocktail of opinions..

Monday, June 08, 2009

33% reservation - another political tokenism

Congress Party of India is back to doing what it does the best. Pander to its votebank through divisive ways. Arjun Singh did it to the education sector few years back. They now want to bring a 33% reservation for females in the parliament. Their rationale: that would ensure the plight of women in the country. I find it quite undemocratic, almost bordering on autocracy, that a random female, on the basis of 'reservation' would be better placed to improve the plight of women in a given constituency than a democratically elected representative. If this bill is really passed, I can see how it would turn out to be. 60 years of reservation in the educational sector for SCs/STs hasnt improved their plight, and the reservation is continued to be (mis)used by the creamy layer of those castes. Ditto for women's bill. The educated 'city-socialites' who have always been away from the heat-n-dust of the real India would use this to the best of their advantage to get an added tag of MP to flaunt in their high society parties. While their partying is none of my business, but their commitment to changing people's life is. In addition, given that the current parliament has close to 70% of women MPs who are related to an influential politican, I wouldnt be surprised if all the male MPs whose constituency is 'reserved' for women put up their wives/daughters for election. Mockery of democracy.

The best thing, in my opinion, to really help women's plight across the country is to give more opportunities and incentives to educated women to join grass root politics across the party-lines. These grass-root workers are the ones who really come in touch with common men/women on a regular basis. When these people work their way up to power corridors, they form a much efficient set of administrator (eg Nitish Kumar). Once we have enough women grass-root workers, that would automatically lead to a higher representation in the parliament. THIS is where our so-called educated cabinet ministers are losing the plot. If you dont have enough women politicans at the grass-root, it is only natural that you wont see enough representation of women in the parliament. This is similar to what we see in the education sector. If you dont have enough women STUDYING engineering, how can you expect to have higher proportion of female engineers in companies. I had discussed this in detail here.

Congress had 60 years of misrule with a fiery Indira Gandhi at help for close to a decade. If THAT couldnt change the plight of the country, how would anything else? With a puppet female president, a female deputy speaker, Congress is an epitome of tokenism. I feel sorry for poor Indian electorate who cannot see through the games played by Congress to stay in power. Last 5 years were indeed a low point as far as Government's record on security is concerned. It still won. Congres has thrived on tokenism and gimmick politics. Infact, this tokenism is what defines Congress. It is in the interest of the party to keep the poor, poor. That's where it gets votes from. Pop in a gimmick NREGS (rural employment guarantee scheme), and you have your votes secured. Don't get me wrong - rural employement scheme sure help the poor, but where is the roadmap to remove poverty as has been promised in the manifesto? Heck, the number of people below the poverty line has actually gone up. Give them a candy, keep them hungry. THAT is tokenism. Just like Laloo's policy in Bihar when he was the CM, it is in Congress' interests to have people below poverty line. I find a similar attitude behind bringing up women's reservation bill.

Women have gone through and are going through a lot even today - in the 21st century - in rural India. These so-called leaders should focus their plight instead of politicizing the matter and thinking that a bunch of high society spice girls in the parliament are going to come up with an elixir for them.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

As an Indian woman, and an independent one at that, I couldn't agree more with what you are saying here. Looks like congress wants to be back to where it was a decade back...

Men's Rights said...

Do you want Women's Reservation everywhere? That is,

1) Women's Reservation for 50% of Judges positions in High Courts and Supreme Court.

2) Women's Reservation for 50% of positions in IAS, IPS, IFS?

3) Women's Reservation for 30% of Govt and Private Sector Company Jobs and Promotions every year without considering performance.

4) Women's Reservation for 50% of Senior Management positions in private sector?

5) Women's Reservation for 50% of seats in IITs, IIMs, Engineering and Medical Colleges?

6) Lay Offs only for men in Private sector and No Lay offs for women.

7) Law for sacking of Men from their jobs, if a woman accuses him of harassment at workplace and considering the accused man guilty till proven innocent.

8) Women's Reservation for 50% of positions in Panchayats.


If you do not want special privileges for Women in all the above, the time to act is now. If women get reservation in parliament, then they will change laws to implement all of the above and you will just watch helplessly.

Jago India. Jago!!

Act Now. Send this message to as many people as possible.

Say No to Special Privileges to Women. Say No to Women's Reservation.

creativelychallenged said...

Hi. I was planning to blog about the women's reservation issue but you articulated my thoughts exactly. These gimmicks help noone.
And I read about some of the stuff you are trying to do in Bihar and as your state mate :P I wish you all the best in your endeavours. I too plan to do something in my village in Bihar, but that's a few years away from now and from a microfinance perspective.

jitendra said...

Hello state-mate :)
Thanks! Good luck to you too. I am actually waiting for that 'tipping point' that our efforts would bring about. That's when a visible change will happen. We are thinking of a coming up with revenue-generating business model that makes the projects self-sustainable. Are you in b-school btw?

Anonymous said...

Good evening

We do not agree with this year BRITs 2010 decision.

Please attend our little web poll

http://micropoll.com/t/KDqOnZBCWt

Lady Gaga can not be better than heavy metal

Poll supported by BRIT awards 2010 sponsor femmestyle
[url=http://www.femmestyle.ch/schoenheitschirurgie/brustvergroesserung/index.html]brustvergrößerung[/url]

BRITs.co.uk - tickets left standing!! This Competition is now closed
OK

Anonymous said...

Nice to see you back. And again by having an interesting post.

Anonymous said...

Just how much can a company legally charge to allow an insurance policy holder out of his insurance?
How much does your company cost when somebody chooses to stop and how much pressure can you use to maintain them?
What are some suggestions or something we can say if our customer has several months remaining on his present auto plan? Undoubtedly, all of us are not going to wait until his renewal comes due every time.